| YEAR | NAME | YEAR | NAME |
| 1975 | Larry Wright #2 | 2011 | Mike England #3260 |
| 1978 | Jack Turner #65 | 2012 | John Fatura #27479 |
| 1982 | Jim Thole #410 | 2016 | Joe Germino #24997 |
| 1985 | Lew Cady #98, Jim McCoy #136 | 2018 | Mark Crane #15584 |
| 1992 | Marcia Butterbaugh #6560 | 2019 | George Miller #17782 |
| 1994 | Don Hicks #16600 | 2020 | Bill Boyles #1454 |
| 1996 | Tobi Hicks #586, Herb Schwarz #1922 | 2020 | Tom Legeret #2179 |
| 1999 | Dave Ohlendorf #1603 | 2021 | Clayton Emery #32806 |
| 2000 | Bruce Gregg #248 | 2022 | "Father" Phil Pospychala #481 |
| 2004 | Bob Campbell #1178 | 2023 | Jim Wolf #16033 |
| 2007 | Marcella Schinski # 3725 | 2024 | Keith Kerschner #11507 |
| 2008 | Ron Jones #1236 | 2024 | Dan Bora #27235 |
| 2009 | Tom Hull #13294 | 2025 | Dan Jeziorski #25960 |
| 2010 | "Beer Dave" Gausepohl #22373 | 2026 | Robert Fondren #14138 |